About the work
A closer look.
Send me up to 3,000 words of your writing and one line about what it's for. I read it from outside and send back, in writing: what actually landed, where I lost the thread, the line doing the real work, and the one change I'd make first. This is a read of your pages as a reader meets them, not a line-by-line proofread. One revision of my notes included. Delivered within 5 days. Before you pay: send me your opening line or first page (up to 500 words) and I'll send back the one thing I'd keep, free, once per person. Judge the taste first. A sample, so you can judge the read before you buy. A page of mine: "The ferry pulled out at six. Anna stood at the rail, her coffee going cold in both hands. She had left the apartment without waking him." My read: the only sentence with a decision is "She had left the apartment without waking him." Everything else watches Anna; that one indicts her. That is the spine, buried under a coffee cup. Cut the announcements and open on the act. Search words: outside read, beta read, feedback on my writing, critique my story, edit my essay, manuscript feedback, first chapter feedback, writing feedback, developmental read, close read.
Before you order
Shop policies
Send one piece, up to 3,000 words, plus one line about what it's for and who it's for. I send back a written read: what holds, what doesn't, and the one change I'd make first. One revision of my notes included. Delivery within 5 days. Tell me your opening line and I'll read it free before you pay.